U.S. Income Tax Issues Faced by Foreign Owned Corporations
Part 1: United States Tax Laws - A Perspective for Foreign Companies and Individuals
Doing Business or Living in the United States
Accounting year for tax purposes
U.S. Tax Law requires that a U.S. corporation controlled by a foreign corporation
have the same tax year-end as the parent corporation.
Payments to related foreign persons
Recently, the Internal Revenue Service issued a notice that requires a U.S. taxpayer
to defer the deduction for expenses accrued to a related foreign person. The deduction
is deferred until the time the expense is actually paid. Final regulations have
not been issued giving guidance on if this rule applies to all accrued expenses
or if it will apply only to expenses such as interest and royalties. This is discussed
in more detail in Exhibit 1.
Withholding tax on amounts paid to foreign persons
Dividends, interest, and royalties a U.S. company pays to its parent are subject
to a 30% withholding tax. The tax is required to be withheld from the payment by
the U.S. company and deposited with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) at the time
of payment. In addition to the withholding tax requirement, the U.S. company must
also satisfy certain reporting requirements. This is discussed in more detail in
Under U.S. tax law, interest paid on a loan from a company's foreign parent generally
is tax deductible by the U.S. company. On the other hand, payments made by the U.S.
company to its foreign parent in connection with its stock is considered dividends,
to the extent of accumulated Earnings & Profits (E & P), and are not deductible
by the U.S. company. In either case, the amounts received by the parent company
are subject to a 30% withholding tax. Payments to the parent in the form of interest
rather that a dividend will, therefore, reduce the company's U.S. tax.
Under U.S. tax law, debt may be recharacterized as equity if the company's ratio
of debt to equity is not considered reasonable. Both the IRS and case law have developed
criteria for determining if the debt to equity ratio is reasonable. If the U.S.
company is too thinly capitalized (i.e., too much debt and too little equity), payments
considered as deductible interest on debt may be recharacterized as a nondeductible
dividend. This is discussed in more detail in Exhibit 3.
Low or no interest rate loans
Under U.S. tax law, the IRS may impute additional interest in case the rate of interest
on a loan from the Foreign parent to its U.S. subsidiary is below the market rate.
The effect is that the subsidiary would received a deduction for the additional
interest imputed and the parent would recognize interest income for the same amount.
This effect could result in either positive or negative tax consequences depending
on the facts. This is discussed in more detail in Exhibit 4.
Tax Accounting Elections
Under U.S. tax law, there are various elections that need to be made by each U.S.
company, many of which must be made in its first year. Failure to make these elections
may create undesirable tax results. This is discussed in more detail in Exhibit
Tax return filing requirements
Every corporation doing business in the United States is required to file applicable
federal and state income tax returns following each annual tax period. This is discussed
in more detail in Exhibit 6.
Uniform capitalization for inventory
Under U.S. tax law, corporations which either manufacture or resell inventory are
required to capitalize a portion of their general and administrative and other costs
into inventory. The allocable costs are expensed as the inventory is sold rather
that when the cost is incurred. There are various methods on how a company may elect
to capitalize costs and which costs are required to be capitalized.
Alternative minimum tax
Often, tax laws will permit a corporation to create tax deductions which significantly
reduce their book income resulting in a low or no tax liability. The corporate alternative
minimum tax may impose a minimum tax on a corporation with no or low general income
tax liability. This is accomplished by disallowing or modifying certain deductions
for alternative minimum tax purposes.
Reporting of cash transactions over $10,000 U.S.
United States law requires banks and other individuals and businesses to prepare
and file an information return when cash amounts exceeding $10,000 are received
(Form 8300, Appendix B).
Most states have a system of taxing corporations which are "doing business" within
their state. Under the tax laws of most states, a company may be considered "doing
business" in the state if it engages in the following activities:
- Maintains an office or place of business in the state,
- Maintains a stock of inventory in the state,
- Solicits sales in the state through an employee located in the state.
These are only a few of the activities which may constitute doing business. Also,
there are activities a company can perform in some states which do not constitute
doing business. Generally, if the company has any type of business activity in a
state, we recommend that you contact us to determine the company's need to file
tax returns and pay income tax in that state.
Survey of foreign direct investment in the United States
The Bureau of Economic Analysis requires all U.S. businesses that are owned 10%
or more by foreign persons (individuals or corporations) to file a Survey of Foreign
Direct Investment in the United States. The purpose of this survey is to measure
the economic significance of foreign direct investment and to analyze its effects
on the U.S. economy. This survey has no tax implications. Generally, a survey is
required to be filed annually. However, for companies with gross receipts or total
assets greater than $20 million, a quarterly survey may be required. Also, there
are various types of surveys which are required depending on the size of the company.
This is discussed in more detail in Exhibit 7.
Organization and start-up expenditures
United States tax laws require that expenses related to the organization and start
up of a company be capitalized. These expenses are not allowed to be deducted currently,
but, if elected by the taxpayer, may be amortized and deducted over a period not
less than 60 months. This is discussed in more detail in Exhibit 8.
Corporation tax planning prior to beginning business in the United States
A review of the proposed U.S. operations, including its structure, financing, ownership
and business plans, should be undertaken with knowledgeable U.S. legal and income
tax advisers, to develop the optimal strategy for the organization and operation
of the U.S. business enterprise. Examples of areas which require careful planning
are transfer pricing between the U.S. and the foreign entity, and preserving the
net operating loss carryforwards of the U.S. entity.
The issue of the proper transfer price between related parties arises frequently
upon government review of corporation income tax returns. The general rule imposed
by U.S. tax authorities is transfer pricing should reflect independent, arms-length
pricing, without shifting economic profit from one jurisdiction to another. Contemporaneous
record keeping which demonstrates economic justification for pricing decisions should
be maintained by the corporation. Hundreds of pages of case law and regulation govern
corporate practice in this area, and careful planning is required to uphold the
desired transfer price.